Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: I love animals, they're delicious.
Posted By: julian, on host 194.213.87.193
Date: Tuesday, May 22, 2001, at 04:40:02
In Reply To: Re: I love animals, they're delicious. posted by Libby on Monday, May 21, 2001, at 22:51:40:

> > Reasons why I eat animals.
> >
> > 1) I don't see anything wrong with eating animals.
>
> Well what if I said that I didn't see anything wrong with eating you???? That wouldn't make it right!! Animals are alive too and deserve our respect!!!
>

I'll agree with wintermute on this one, but I'd like to make comments of my own (pats on the head for being independent ;-)) below.


> >
> > 2) Its not like animals have anything better to do then sit on my plate.
>
> What about bringing up their young or living their own lives, in peace? Do you have nothing better to do than sit on a plate!? Animals are living things just like you and me!!
>

'Peace' is a utopian state. As far as I'm concerned, humanity has made only miniscule steps towards a peaceful society, where everyone can mind there chosen business without fearing interference from anyone - is this how paradise looks like? If this is the case, there must logically be a growing number of paradises. Anyway, what I meant to state is this: No, not "just like you and me". By nature (or achievement, you decide) we are higher up the food chain than most animals. Since a food chain is an accurate model of the way Nature works, I beleive that is is 'natural' for us to eat animals.


> >
> > 3) Its not inhumane, one quick cut and they're dead.
>
> Even if that was true (which it is not!!) it wouldn't be very much help. How would you like it if I kidnapped you when you were a baby, kept you in a box, and then made one quick cut until you were dead?? Probably wouldn't be much consoleation!

I'll agree with you on this one. With my limited knowledge of modern food industry (an accurate term, I beleive), I'd say that the meat we buy from stores often comes from inhumanely treated animals, especially the 'keeping in a box' thing. I'm not sure about the "quick cut" either, but I'd have to say that I don't really know for sure.


>
> >
> > 4) Meat is good.
>
> So is money. Doesn't mean I'm going to rob a bank for it!!
>

Bingo!

> >
> > 5) Meat is a good source of protien. I know you can get from beans, but who wants to have gas all night?
> >
> > -Help
>
> I don't mean to be rude on my first post but you happened to pick an issue very close to my heart (I'm a vegan). There are plenty of other protien sources. You don't need meat to be healthy and happy. Meat is murder, and it's no better than eating humans!! You wouldn't eat a human, but a cow is fine? The thing is a cow is probably better than a human because how many wars have cows started? Think on that for a bit...
>

Vegans (not me) get their meat-like proteins primarily from eggs.

I realise that 'murder' is a no-no word for many. None the less, the harsh reality is that, yes, it is natural for humans to 'murder' animals for food (and plenty of other things). Get used to it, 'cause I dare say you wouldn't be alive if this were not the case.
That said, there is one very good reason for not buying meat (and becoming politicaly active), and that is the way (a large part of) the meat industry treats the animals.


> Lib "New to Rinkworks please don't think I'm too mean! Hehe. Did I do this right?" by

jul"I'm not sure I should be the one to welcome you since I haven't been here for a while"ian

Replies To This Message