Main      Site Guide    
Message Forum
Re: Are Native Americans lazy and weak?
Posted By: Howard, on host 205.184.139.46
Date: Tuesday, January 25, 2000, at 17:18:48
In Reply To: Re: Are Native Americans lazy and weak? posted by Tranio on Tuesday, January 25, 2000, at 13:06:28:

> > Thought I'd share this little anectdote from yesterday's American Literature class:
> >
> > While discussing William Wells Brown's _Clotel_, the conversation naturally progressed to the American slave trade, and why it thrived for as long as it did, the nature of enslavement, the concept of the social "other", and why it was/is so easy to dehumanize this "other.
> >
> > The professor started on a tangent regarding the Native Americans, and the first settlers' opinion of them. He then posed the question "Why did the settlers not enslave the Native Americans?"
> >
> > Among other ridiculous answers were these two gems:
> >
> > "Because they wouldn't have made good slaves. Indians are thin and weak."
> >
> > and...
> >
> > "Because they wouldn't have worked as hard as other slaves. Indians are lazy."
> >
> > Each of these responses were followed by a look of fright on the professor's face (though surprisingly few students shared his expression). He asked "Where did you learn that?" And they each confidently replied: "In high school."
> >
> > Now, I went to an white, conservative, relatively culturally-insensitive high school, and even *I* was never taught such trash. So now I'm wondering, where is this sort of thing professed?
> >
> > This all, by the way, took place in a so-called upper-level course at a major university.
> >
> > Gr"somewhat frightened"ace
>
> That's terribly offensive in a couple of ways. First of all, what teacher in their right mind could possibly decide that it would be a good idea to teach such a thing to their students?!

It's not always the teachers. Things like that show up in textbooks. A major problem with education is that teachers are told what to teach and how to teach it. Teachers who don't conform get a lot of flac. I speak from experience.

I'm beginning to believe some of you really did read "Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee." That's another thing I like about RinkWorks. No bigots.
Howard